Traditional Vs Modern Flamenco
The fuzzy boundaries of tradition
No sensible person would try to define where traditional ends and modern begins. Sabicas played traditional
music but he also played some pretty unusual stuff that could hardly be defined as flamenco. However, I think
it would be fair to say that before Paco de Lucia introduced his sextet to the world, complete with flutes,
bongos and fretless electric bass, the average person on the street had a rough idea of what flamenco was
about. Not any more.
Although I enjoy listening to the more modern interpretations of traditional forms by genuine flamenco artists such
as Paco de Lucia and Gerardo Nunez, at the end of the day I still prefer the older stuff. This provides a reference
that is, for the most part, unashamedly standard in it's presentation.
As a guitarist with only a simple wooden box in my hand, it becomes increasingly more difficult to relate to
some of the lavish productions released on CD these days. Having said that, I am irresistibly drawn to listen
to this modern style of flamenco anyway. Compared to the mind boggling technical abilities of these modern
guitar players I am just a struggling amateur.
Humbling as it is to listen to this stuff, I draw great inspiration from it all. But it's sometimes easy to
forget that without the work of the past masters to act as guide, modern flamenco would never have evolved into
what it is today. So much for the ongoping evolution of traditional flamenco.
What about the other stuff that is erroneously referred to as 'New Flamenco.' What is promoted by main stream
music companies as flamenco is an entirely different animal. These days the word flamenco is loosely attached
to any sort of Latin pop by artists like the Gipsy Kings, Armik and such. While I give full credit to these
successful artists and acknowledge their talent, I have an issue with the manner in which these artists are
promoted. The exotic form of fusion lounge music played by Ottmat Liebert and similar artists is also openly
promoted as flamenco in music stores. I don't know about you, but this laid back supermarket music makes me
think of coconut trees and footprints in the sand. I have no idea what the flamenco connection is supposed to
And yet real flamenco CDs, if you can find them at all, are relegated to the World music section or some other
obscure category. There is nothing bad or evil or wrong with the so called 'New Flamenco' of today. It is all
good music and worth listening to, but it is certainly NOT real flamenco by any stretch of the imagination, and
never will be.
Here's a question
How come I keep hearing this so called 'New Flamenco' piped through tinny speakers in elevators and shopping
malls? Fair enough. It's good background music and it's soothing. But I cannot remember the last time I heard
real flamenco artists like Sabicas or Paco de Lucia in an elevator.
The bottom line is that the word flamenco sounds exotic and sells CDs for promoters and recording companies who
have brainwashed the general public with their misinformed hype. But this is not about them. The point is that
the traditional flamenco roots from which these modern artists draw their inspiration will always be there. You
can try to change public perception about flamenco and you can even attempt to re-define the word, but you
can't change history.